Jakarta in Hot Seat On British Mission

The Jakarta Globe

All fingers were pointing to the Jakarta administration after the British Embassy relocated its offices in response to the dismantling of security barriers on the road leading to its building opposite the Hotel Indonesia traffic circle.

A spokesman for the city, however, has denied any knowledge of the relocation.
Two boom gates, set up more than 12 years ago as part of the embassy’s perimeter security, were pulled down on May 20 after complaints from residents about the inconvenience of having to go through the security checks.
Since then, media reported, the embassy has relocated to an adjacent building. The embassy did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Sr. Comr. Suntana, director of the Jakarta Police’s vital facilities unit, said that while his office was involved in taking down the gates, it was the city’s decision.
“All I know is the governor [Fauzi Bowo] said the road was a public one, so the gates had to be removed,” he said. “We just did what he wanted.”
He added that while the embassy had requested the barriers be put back up, the governor had insisted against it.
Cucu Ahmad Kurniawan, a spokesman for the Jakarta administration, said he had not received the news about the embassy’s relocation.
He added that he would “coordinate with the transportation office and the [Central Jakarta] municipality” to find a solution to the problem.
Cucu said the administration would “immediately ensure security” at the embassy, although he did not say whether this meant replacing the gates.
Suntana said that even without the gates, the embassy was still safe from threats. “In terms of security, that’s a very safe area,” he said. “We always have personnel on guard there.”
He added there were always at least six police officers stationed outside the embassy, while backup was available from the police post at the traffic circle.
Ignacio Kristanyo Hardojo, director for diplomatic security at the Foreign Ministry, said his office was seeking a “win-win solution that can accommodate the wishes of the Menteng residents and the security needs of the British Embassy, because we want to solve this problem as soon as possible.”
“However, it needs to be understood that Indonesia has the same standard of security for all foreign embassies in Jakarta, including the British Embassy, where we want to create a sense of safety,” he said.
“Hopefully we’ll have a solution by next week.”
Last month, Rudy Pamaputra, who owns the building adjacent to the embassy, said the gates had caused problems for both his staff and clients. He has owned the building since 1975 but opened a golf simulator on the premises only five years ago.
Rudy said he had been complaining to the embassy since the gates went up in 1998.
“My clients are reluctant to come here because not only do they have to pass through the portals, but they must also go through security checks,” he said last month. “This is a public road but the embassy treats it as its own, especially with the security officers who are so arrogant.”

It’s Not That Bad at Mt. Dieng: Officials

The Jakarta Globe

Inaccurate information about poisonous gases said to be spewing from all craters of Mount Dieng in Central Java has caused a sharp drop in visitors to the area, officials said on Thursday.


Winarno Sudjas from the Ministry of Culture and Tourism told the Jakarta Globe that soon after reports were published that the entire Dieng plateau was emitting poisonous gases, tourism there dropped to 70 percent of the normal average of 1,500 visitors per day.

“It is very important that the PVMBG informs the public again in detail about Mount Dieng’s status — about the danger zone and the places that the people can and cannot visit,” he said, referring to the Volcanology and Geographical Disaster Mitigation Agency.
The Dieng Plateau is one of the most popular tourist destinations in Central Java. It combines culture and nature as it is the site of eight small Hindu temples from the 7th and 8th centuries, while it is also the location of colorful sulfur lakes.
Mount Dieng has six craters: Sileri, Siglagah, Condrodimuko, Sikidang, Sinila and Timbang. According to scientists, the latter two are the most active.
PVMBG chief Surono said on Thursday that the only dangerous area at the Dieng Plateau was that surrounding the Timbang crater. “It is not true that all the craters in Mount Dieng cannot be visited. In fact, the only place that cannot be visited is the Timbang crater,” Surono said.
He added that the PVMBG had declared a one-kilometer radius around that specific crater off-limits to the public .
The other craters can safely be visited, Surono said, because the Timbang crater emissions do not pose a threat for locations outside of the designated radius.
Umar Rosadi, the head of the Emergency Response Team at the PVMBG, said the level of carbon dioxide in the air at the Timbang crater had a volume percentage of 1.65 on Thursday. A percentage greater than 0.5 is dangerous for humans.
Just like carbon monoxide, which is also being emitted at the crater, carbon dioxide is colorless, odorless and toxic at high levels. The gases are difficult to trace. The Indonesian Red Cross (PMI) has been distributing face masks to people in the area.
Since Sunday, the government has relocated more than 1,100 people living in the area to shelters in nearby Batur subdistrict.
Sutopo Purwo Nugroho, a spokesman for the National Disaster Mitigation Agency (BNPB), said the agency is assisting its local branch office in drawing up contingency plans.
According to Sutopo, the BNPB has given the local office Rp 250 million ($29,000) to buy food for people in the shelters.

Semanggi Shops Say Traffic Barrier Killing Business

The Jakarta Globe

The concrete barricade blocking off the entrance to Plaza Semanggi mall from Jalan Gatot Subroto has disrupted business as it discourages visitors who are unwilling to take a longer route to get to the shopping center, store owners said on Tuesday.


Subur, who opened an electronics shop on the ground floor of the South Jakarta retail center almost seven years ago, said his revenue had dropped dramatically since the city had closed off the westbound entrance to ease congestion.

“My shop income has dropped as much as 50 to 70 percent per month since the closure in September,” he said.

Subur said fellow shop owners had also cited the same problem and some had even closed down due to the declining number of visitors, which they attributed to the closure.

“Lets remember that there are many people working here not only to provide for themselves but also for their family at home,” he said. He added that he did not think the concrete barriers had in any way helped to reduce congestion in the area.

Triyani, a shopkeeper at the Micel Boutique, repeated Subur’s complaint, saying that the shop’s revenue has dropped from about Rp 40 million ($4,500) per month to about Rp 20 million.

“We usually contact our customers by SMS when we have a new collection, but lately many of them said they don’t like coming to Plaza Semanggi because they have to take a longer route,” Triyani said.

The barrier issue was thrust into the spotlight last week when members of the Indonesian Legion of Veterans (LVRI) began a campaign of repeatedly removing the barriers in the face of police warnings.

The veterans, who earn money from the rental of the land and its buildings by the Lippo Group’s shopping mall division, say the traffic diversion is cutting into mall revenues so severely that their income is threatened.

Police have threatened to punish the veterans for tampering with city property.

Dewi, who works for a mobile phone shop on the second floor of the mall, said the owner of the store had complained to the mall’s management about the falling foot traffic.

“Every month, we have to pay Rp 6 million for the rent and we used to earn Rp 20 million to Rp 30 million per month. Now, we only earn Rp 10 million, while we are paying the same amount of money [for rent],” Dewi said.

And it is not only shopkeepers and employees that are complaining about the situation.

Taxi driver Lili Rusli, who must often take roundabout detours to ferry passengers to the mall, believes the main culprits of the frequent traffic jams on Gatot Subroto are the busway stop and a nearby toll road entrance, which backs up traffic during rush hours.

“When there are more than one buses at the bus stop, it immediately causes traffic on Gatot Subroto,” Lili said.

Lili said that he often had to listen to passenger complaints regarding the entrance closure.

“I have heard many complaints from the passengers,” he said. “But what can I really do other than giving them an option between being dropped in front of the Crown Plaza Hotel [further down the road] past the barricade, or we have to take a longer route, which means they have to pay more on the fare.”

Another taxi driver, Supriadi said he believed the barricade had increased traffic in the area and he also bemoaned complaints from angry riders.

“My passengers often get mad at me because they cannot be dropped inside of the Plaza Semanggi area. But this is not really my fault because they do not come from the ‘right’ direction to go to Plaza Semanggi,” he said.

H. M. Aziz M., a spokesman for LVRI, said his group would stop removing the barriers once the city made good on a promise to provide an alternate route to the mall as promised.

“They said they will have the alternative route ready in April 2011. But where is it?” he said.

Nation Suffering as National Ideology is Neglected: Citizens

The Jakarta Globe

Sixty-six years since the state ideology of Pancasila was enshrined in the national conscience, its messages of religious tolerance, pluralism and social justice are being ignored, officials and ordinary citizens say.


Hajriyanto Thohari, deputy chairman of the People’s Consultative Assembly (MPR), said true social justice, where the welfare of the people was prioritized over the interests of the elite, was still a long way off.

“Just look at the state budget,” he said on Tuesday. “Sixty percent of it goes toward civil servants’ pay and overheads. At the regional level it’s even worse, at around 80 percent.”

He said that with so little spent on public needs and an estimated 31 million people still living below the poverty line, there had been a clear failure to fully adopt Pancasila.

“Where’s the social justice?” he asked. “Corruption cases, abuse of power — it makes people even more pessimistic about Pancasila.”

Eva Kusuma Sundari, a legislator with the Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle (PDI-P), said the recent spate of religious violence was proof that the goal of tolerance had not yet been attained.

She said it was important to have a firm leader who could ensure that the values of Pancasila were not violated.

“That way, we can more effectively nurture these principles in society,” Eva said.

Prof. Sutaryo, the chief adviser at Gadjah Mada University’s (UGM) Pancasila Study Center, said the reforms implemented since the end of the New Order era were responsible for the loss of adherence to the values of the ideology.

He said that since the downfall of President Suharto, several regulations and bylaws had been issued that discouraged the adoption of Pancasila by the country’s youth, including a regulation that scrapped the teaching of the ideology at schools.

But Siti Marsha Wena, a seventh-grade student, was more hopeful about Pancasila’s prospects.

“The third point of Pancasila is on the unity of Indonesia and calls for mutual respect,” she said. “I don’t like to see my friends fighting over something because that doesn’t show any unity among us. So in order to foster unity, we need to respect one another.”

Eduardo Andhika Kurninawan, a recent high school graduate about to enroll at UGM, agreed that tolerance and mutual respect were important in returning to the spirit of the ideology.

“We need to keep in mind that this is democratic country where everyone is free to express their opinions,” he said. “There’s nothing wrong in expressing our opinions, as long as we don’t force our points of view on others.”

The five principles of the Pancasila were first proposed by President Sukarno on June 1, 1945.

Parents Say School Pressed Kids to Cheat

The Jakarta Globe


The parents of a sixth-grader at a South Jakarta elementary school have filed a complaint claiming the school provided students with answers to the national exams prior to testing in May.

The parents allege the school, identified as State Elementary School (SDN) No. 6 Pesanggrahan, initially provided answers to a handful of students, then had them distribute the answers to the rest of the student body by cellphone. These efforts, the parents told the National Commission for Child Protection (Komnas Anak), involved their own son, identified only as M.A.P.
Commission chairman Arist Merdeka Sirait said the complaint was filed on Saturday.
“We believe there is evidence of systematic fraud,” he told the Jakarta Globe on Sunday.
“Additionally, we believe this not only occurred at M.A.P.’s school, but at others as well.”
He said his office would investigate the case, but even if the allegations proved to be true, it would not impose punishments.
“It’s not fair if the school helped its students cheat during the national exams,” Arist said. “But [the Education Ministry is] not demanding that the guilty parties be punished.”
He stressed, however, that the allegation undermined the credibility of the exams themselves.
Winda Lubis, M.A.P’s mother, told the Globe on Monday that she found out about the systematic cheating when her son returned home crying after the first day of the exams.
“He told me his teacher had told him and three other students to give the exam answers to the other students during the test,” she said.
“However, they were told not to tell anyone about this, including their parents.”
She said that after learning about this, she had tried to file a complaint at one of the posts set up by the Education Ministry for that very purpose.
“When I tried to call the first time, there wasn’t any response. The second day, an office boy answered and said the complaint post was closed because it was set up to accommodate reports of cheating in the junior and senior high school exams,” Winda said.
“So I reported the case to Komnas Anak because that was the only alternative.”
However, Taufik Yudi Mulyanto, head of the Jakarta Education Office, told the Globe that the complaint had been noted.
“We first received the complaint [on Friday] and we have already followed up on it,” he said.
“But we haven’t found any evidence [to support the allegations]. Even if we do, we don’t know yet what we’ll do about it.”
Bambang Wisudo, executive director of the nongovernmental group Schools Without Borders, said it was a shame that teachers were fostering a culture of cheating among young students.
He also said that requiring sixth-graders to take exams to proceed to junior high school placed undue pressure on them.
“The national exams can destroy the children at a basic level because the standardization of the tests is flawed and the implementation can force students to cheat,” he said.
“Instead of being forced to take the exams, the children should be allowed to develop based on their interests.”
Winda said she had gone public with the issue because she believed that cheating at such a young age posed a moral danger to the country’s children.
“I know there are many potential risks that I’ve exposed my son to by revealing this case, but I just care about my children’s education,” she said.
“To develop the nation on the basis of a smart work force means nothing if that work force lacks morals. We need to nurture honest people.”

Alert Raised Over Volcano’s Deadly Gas

The Jakarta Globe


Authorities have raised the alert level for Mount Dieng in Central Java and have ordered the evacuation of residents living near the area after the volcano began spewing poisonous gas.

Sutopo Purwo Nugroho, a spokesman for the National Disaster Mitigation Agency (BNPB), said on Monday that the alert status was raised from level 2 to level 3, which meant the volcano was showing signs of erupting.
He said scientists recorded increasing volcanic activity on Sunday. “There was phreatic eruption [a steam eruption without lava] which happened at the Timbang crater, one of the active craters,” Sutopo said.
He said the crater spouted jets of carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide — both colorless and odorless.
Mount Dieng has six craters: Sileri, Siglagah, Condrodimuko, Sikidang, Sinila and Timbang. Scientists say the latter two are the most active.
Sutopo added that the Volcanology and Geological Disaster Mitigation Agency (PVMBG) had declared a one-kilometer radius around Timbang off-limits. Several villages were covered by the danger zone.
“We have evacuated 1,179 people from Simbar and Sumber villages to [a village in] Batur subdistrict,” Sutopo said.
PVMBG chief Surono said on Monday that Mount Dieng’s eruption was marked by the emission of gas, which if inhaled in large amounts could be fatal.
He said that in 1979, CO2 from the Timbang crater killed 149 people. During the rainy season, the greenhouse gas stays close to the surface of the earth, making it deadlier, Surono added.
Muhammad Djasri, the Banjarnegara district chief, said the government on Monday declared a state of emergency in the area through to June 12.
Sarkono, head of Batur subdistrict, said that although residents in the danger zone had already been evacuated, many villagers were sneaking back to the Mount Dieng area to tend to their land and livestock.

Survey Finds 80% of People Still Find Pancasila Relevant

The Jakarta Globe

Most people still see Pancasila as relevant and believe there is a need to apply the values of the state ideology in their daily lives, a survey released on Tuesday shows.


For three decades under the iron-fisted rule of President Suharto, the teaching of the state ideology was obligatory at all schools, but once he stepped down in 1998, the compulsory nature was dropped.

But a recent survey by the Central Statistics Agency (BPS) found that most people long for a return to the days when the ideology was taught in all schools, across the country, giving it equal footing with the state’s six recognized religions.

“About 80 percent see Pancasila as something that is still needed,” BPS chairman Rusman Heriawan said at the State Palace before reporting the results of the survey to President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono.

The survey, conducted from May 27-29, questioned 12,000 randomly selected people from various backgrounds throughout the country, asking for their opinion of and understanding of the state ideology.

“This [the result] might be in response to growing incidents of unrest,” Rusman said, referring to the mounting number of recent cases of religious-based violence around the country.

The survey also revealed that most respondents had hopes that Pancasila would be returned to school curricula.

“They feel a lack of implementation [of Pancasila] in their daily lives,” Rusman said.

Pancasila, which means five tenets, was used by Suharto’s New Order regime to keep religious extremism at bay, including by demanding that all political parties and mass organizations adhere to the ideology.

In a private discussion, “Tolerance in Spiritual Lives and a Pluralistic Country,” which was held in Jakarta on Tuesday, religious leaders called on the government to protect both the Constitution and Pancasila.

Speaking at the event, Andreas A. Yewangoe, chairman of the Indonesian Protestant Church Union (PGI), said the country needed to be brought back to Pancasila before other ideologies could destroy it.

“It needs to be understood that we, the religious leaders, are not contemptuous of all government policies or actions, but we just criticize what it has been doing, with the government slowly leaving Pancasila behind,” he said.

Yewangoe cited the Islamic Awards granted by the minister of religious affair to governors, district heads and mayors deemed to “explicitly include Islamic education in regional bylaws.”

“It is not a picture of Pancasila at all, which has values of tolerance and mutual respect, because those district heads and mayors are actually discriminating with the decrees they issue to govern their areas,” he said.

Yewangoe added that Pancasila was the ideal ideology to keep multifaceted Indonesia united.

“The government and all the Indonesian people need to seriously implement Pancasila in their daily lives, including when they make regulations or policy,” he said.

Din Syamsuddin, chairman of Muhammadiyah, the country’s second-largest Islamic organization, said Pancasila was the best ideology to sustain the country.

“Indonesia is a Pancasila country, where we must be tolerant and respect each other,” he said.

He said that to get the values of Pancasila reflected in the nation’s daily life, those who supported the ideology should persuade everyone in the country to embrace its tenets.

Din said the government should also intervene whenever there was a problem of intolerance, and that there was also a need to build common ethical values across religions.

“It is very important that we share common ethical values among the followers of the various faiths,” he said.

Ursula McLackland, regional secretary general of the Universal Peace Federation-Asia, a network that advocates global peace, said the country’s Constitution, which guaranteed freedom of worship, was a good model but its implementation in daily life still needed to be more effective.

Official Confident of Hollywood Ending in Foreign Film Boycott

The Jakarta Globe

Indonesia’s despair over the lack of Hollywood blockbusters on the big screen may be over soon, according to a tourism official.


Ukus Kuswara, the director general for culture, arts and film at the Ministry of Tourism, said the government and the Motion Picture Association had negotiated a “win-win solution.”

“Let’s just say it’s not about the tax figure, but the mechanism for its imposition. There’s a difference in perception but that’s been sorted out now,” he told AFP without elaborating.

The dispute centers on Indonesia’s new system of calculating and charging royalties on imported films, which the MPA said had “a detrimental impact on the cost of bringing a film into Indonesia.”

When asked to clarify, Ukus said the ministry wanted US box-office hits — which made up more than half of all movies screened in Indonesia before the boycott began in February — to return as soo n as possible, largely due to the detrimental impact the boycott has had on the cinema industry.

“I have been monitoring the films [being shown] and cinema visitors, and it’s sad to see theaters empty,” he said.

While the Directorate General of Customs and Excise has been resolute about implementing the new royalty computation, the Ministry of Tourism has always maintained that the government is open to negotiations with film importers.

Ukus said that while it was the government’s right to impose taxes and duties, “we need a way of determining import duties that everyone agrees to.”

“We will have one more meeting with the Ministry of Finance [on Monday] regarding the tax scheme,” he said. “Hopefully, in the next one or two weeks, importers can resume bringing in box-office hits to Indonesia.”

Since the MPA stopped distributing films to Indonesia, everyone has been losing except the sellers of pirated DVDs.

“Customers are looking for titles like ‘Fast Five,’ ‘Black Swan’ and ‘Thor’ because they can’t watch them in the cinema,” said Yani, who sells pirated DVDs. “They complain my videos are low quality and they wouldn’t watch them if they had a choice. But I can’t complain, business is good.”

She said sales had jumped 50 percent since the MPA boycott.

Cinemas, which have been trying to fill the gap with local fare and B-grade foreign films dug out of the rejects bin, are almost empty.

Djonny Sjafruddin, the head of the Indonesian Cinema Companies Union (GPBSI), which represents 240 cinemas nationwide, had earlier said that the foreign film distribution boycott had caused a 60 percent drop in the local cinema industry’s income nationwide.

Worse may be yet to come, with “Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2” also likely to be axed, Djonny added.

But if the issue is indeed resolved in the next one or two weeks, as Usuk said, Potter fans might not have to fly to Singapore to see the much-awaited conclusion of the blockbuster series.

Additional reporting by AFP

Indonesia’s Transgender Community Facing Test of Faith

The Jakarta Globe


For Indonesian transgenders, practicing religion in public is not an easy thing, but that doesn’t stop some from trying.
Mariyani, a 50-year-old transgender hairdresser, said during a discussion on homosexuality and religion that transgender people, just like other people, wish to be able to practice their religion openly.
“If I ever had the choice, I would not want to be a transgender, but this is what God has decided for me,” Mariyani said.
“It needs to be understood that it is not true that all transgenders are bad, because there are good transgenders who actually have a strong willingness to publicly practice religion but unfortunately we are not accepted,” she said.
But Merlyn Sopjan, a Christian transgender who heads the Malang Transsexual Association (Iwama), told the Jakarta Globe that unlike Mariyani, she has never experienced rejection in her church.
“Even though there are many people who know that I am a transgender, no one stares at me every time I walk to the church and I feel so comfortable because I can practice my religion peacefully,” Merlyn said.
“I think it is because that in Christian religious rites, the male and female believers are not segregated,” she added.
“However, I have one friend who was told by the priest that he cannot join the Mass if he dresses up as a woman.”
Merlyn said she expects that transgenders will eventually be accepted within religious groups.
“As human beings who are committed to our religion, we just want to have the freedom to practice our religion as other people do,” she added.
Mohamad Guntur Romli, a prominent liberal Muslim intellectual and a graduate of Egypt’s Al Azhar University, said on Thursday that the root cause of suspicion of homosexuals in Indonesia is ignorance.
“The lack of knowledge about rights and health issues related to homosexuality has created hatred within society,” Guntur said.
“Homosexuality is being equated with a mental disorder or the homosexual community is blamed for having spread HIV/AIDS, for instance. That’s not proper information about homosexuality and this has led to homophobia among wider society,” he explained.
Guntur said religious institutions and leaders have also played a role in the stigmatization of homosexuals.
“Religious institutions and leaders often find it difficult to be sympathetic toward homosexuality,” he continued.
He said that self-righteous religious leaders and institutions see homosexuals as sinners.
“Ignorance about homosexuality has created homophobia in society and religion is being used to spread hatred toward homosexual communities,” Guntur added.
Muhammad Syukri, an openly gay man from Yogyakarta, told the Globe on Friday that obvious signs of gayness sometimes lead to rejection.
“Being gay is not as hard as being transgender … whenever I want to practice my religion, I do not get a hard time from another believer, because I do not dress up as a woman,” Syukri said.
But as soon as he would begin acting in what is seen as a feminine way, trouble often starts. “Some people make a fun of me and actually, that is a form of harassment,” Syukri said.

AGO Says It Will Still Go After Teen Over Rp 10,000 Phone Card

The Jakarta Globe

The Attorney General’s Office indicated on Friday that it would continue pursuing a teenager accused of stealing a Rp 10,000 cellphone voucher, despite a recent ruling dismissing the matter.


“We embrace the principle of legality, as long as the crime falls under the criminal charges. This is the theft of phone voucher that falls under the Article 362 [of the Criminal Code],” said Marwan Effendy, the deputy attorney general for internal supervision.

He was commenting on a preliminary court decision rejecting the indictment against Deli Suhendi, 14, and ordered he be cleared of theft charges because, among other things, he was not accompanied by lawyers during the police interrogation.

“For underage children, there are special rules for the trial and detention procedures, but the criminal charges will be the same,” the deputy said.

Marwan said unconventional methods to settle controversial cases were often rejected by the Supreme Court if they were against the principle of legality.

“We once used the ‘sociological’ approach but our decision was overturned by the Supreme Court,” he said, apparently referring to the decision by prosecutors to drop charges against antigraft officials Chandra Hamzah and Bibit Samad Rianto last year.

Prosecutors said “it would be morally harmful than beneficial to try the two officials,” but the top court ruled such an approach was not recognized by the Indonesian judiciary system.

The AGO’s insistence on the trial drew protests from the National Commission for Child Protection (Komnas Anak) for ignoring a regulation that adopts a special approach for children.

“As a prosecutor, Marwan Effendy has violated the 2009 joint ministerial decree on how to deal the children who are in conflict with the law, and if he insists to go through with the case he will set a precedence for other prosecutors,” commission chairman Arist Merdeka Sirait said.

“It needs to be considered that there was no aggrieved person who reported this case, but police reported it themselves and there was no Rp 10,000 credit voucher as the evidence for the trial.”

Supriyadi Sebayang, a lawyer for Deli, told the Jakarta Globe that the defense was ready.

“Although it is surprising that the prosecutor insists to file the appeal against Deli, we are going to fight against the prosecutor.”

“The prosecutor’s willingness to continue with the case has raised question about the motive behind the action, whether there is a fear toward the investigators [police]?” he said.

“This is not a big case, not worth millions of rupiah, but only Rp 10,000 and there is no aggrieved person.”