This Business Sucks: Depok Man Bets on Leeches

The Jakarta Globe

Depok. Leeches may be slimy and suck your blood, but they can also be highly beneficial, said Indonesian leech vendor Wahyu Cromer, adding that his faith in what the worms could do for the human body was so great that he and his friends decided to invest in a leech farm nearly five years ago. 


Today their small farm churns out a profit of Rp 30 million ($3,400) a month at the very least, and growth in the alternative medication therapy, particularly for heart and diabetes patients, is showing no signs of stopping. 

Wahyu remembers how his sickly father suffered his third stroke in 2006, and he had run out of ideas of where to turn to until he heard of alternative leech therapy in Cirebon. He decided to give it a go. 

“Initially my father couldn’t move whatsoever. Within three months of leech therapy, my father started showing significant improvement. I was stunned. I was so satisfied with what leeches could do for my father, I began to scour for information on the medicinal strengths of the leech — and business opportunities,” Wahyu told the Jakarta Globe on Sunday. 

He added that along with business partners Midin Muhidin and Bimala Dewi, he invested in 400 medicinal leeches at a cost of Rp 12 million. Their farm, known as eNHa, is located at the back of Wahyu’s home on Jalan Haji Bona in Limo, Depok. 

“We were excited. I knew the prospects were good so I discussed this with Dewi and Midin. We knew the potential of this business because investing in leeches at the time was a novelty,” Wahyu said. 

Wahyu said it took them a year to find the perfect conditions for the leeches to breed. “Conditions must be humid, dark and free of pollution. Pollution can kill the leech,” he said, adding that the leeches are hermaphrodites. 

The farm is currently home to 22 ponds, each with about 1,000 medicinal leeches. 

“It takes six months before a leech can be used for therapy. We spend just Rp 5 million a month now for operational costs, and make a clean profit of at least Rp 30 million a month.” 

Leech Therapy Clinic 

Last year eNHa established the eNHa Clinic, for leech therapy. 

“Initially we just wanted to make do with the farm, but then the requests came in — many were related to leech therapy. So we opened our clinic,” Midin said, adding that they saw to at least five patients a day with a variety of problems. 

“Leech therapy is your ‘live’ acupuncture therapy. It is therefore very vital to know which points to place the leech on. The number of leeches which are used is different for every patient — it depends on their problems. One patient could use just two, while other patients could use up to 25 leeches. Every patient pays a different price,” Midin said. 

But what happens to leeches after they are used on a human? 

“They are killed — using alcohol — and used as plant fertilizers. It’s the same principle as with needles: We throw them away after we use them, because we have no idea what is inside the patient’s body. We will never use the same leech on another patient,” Wahyu said. 

Before the leeches are used for therapy, they will be quarantined for a few weeks without any food to make sure they suck the patient’s blood. 

“Normally we feed the leeches eel. One pond with 1,000 leeches will need one kilogram of eel, which will satisfy them for a couple of weeks. But the ones that will be used [for therapy] will not be fed and placed in clean water without mud,” Midin said. 

“We are now working together with professors from University of Indonesia, Diponegoro University and also the Bandung Institute of Technology to find out everything we can about the use of the leeches.” 

Supply and Demand 

Dewi, Wahyu’s other partner, said it was difficult to meet demand, as people as from as far as America and Egypt were willing to place orders. 

“Home-based leech therapy is growing like crazy, from the east to the west of Indonesia. We have found ourselves supplying 10,000 leeches throughout the nation each month, and that’s just a small part of the business,” Dewi told the Globe. 

“Requests for leeches have been made from India, South Korea, Egypt and the United States. But unfortunately we have not been able to meet demand for dried leeches [used to make medicinal powder],” she said. “We might in a short time, but it’s hard, even though profits seem very promising. We just don’t want to send customers poor quality leeches.” 

But shipping live leeches oversees also proves difficult. 

“That is what we are trying to learn. But for now, it seems that sending people dried leeches is far more profitable,” Wahyu said. 

He added that in order to be able to meet international demand, he was training 50 people who showed a sincere interest in the leech business. 

But more people are still welcome, Dewi said.

Century Defendant Claims She’s Taking the Fall

The Jakarta Globe

A former senior Bank Century employee whose criminal case has drawn considerable public attention since her blogger daughter published a heartfelt plea on her behalf, in her closing statement to the Central Jakarta District Court on Thursday claimed she was just doing her job.


Arga Tirta Kirana, the since rebranded bank’s former corporate legal division head, denied being ultimately responsible for the disbursement of credit to shady companies without going through the proper procedures while she was working for Bank Century in 2009.

The prosecution is seeking a 10-year jail term and a Rp 10 billion ($1.1 million) fine.

Arga, mother of teenage writer and activist Alanda Kariza, 19, told the court: “I am not the one who is responsible in this case nor have I benefited from it.”

During her 20-minute testimony, Arga claimed she was being made a scapegoat to divert attention from the main issues surrounding the bailout process.

“I have been tyrannized. Hermanus [Hasan Muslim] and Robert Tantular are the ones who are responsible. Why is my sentence demand harsher than theirs? Is the judicial mafia behind this?” Arga said. “I have been set up so I can take the fall.”

Tantular, the disgraced former co-owner of the bank, since renamed Bank Mutiara, was sentenced to nine years in jail, while Hermanus, a former director, received six years.

Arga said she was only following orders at the time the credit was handed out and added that “Hermanus and Robert were looking for somebody to take the fall for the problematic disbursement of funds from the Deposit Insurance Agency [LPS] to Bank Century.”

Arga pleaded with the judge to consider the fate of her children.

“I hope, Your Honor, that you will follow your conscience in reaching your verdict. Nothing worries me more than the fate of my daughters. The youngest is 5 years old and still in kindergarten, my second daughter is 8 years old and the oldest is 19 and still in college. My husband is jobless after being fired from Bank Century in 2008,” she said.

After the hearing, Arga’s lawyer Humphrey Djemat told the Jakarta Globe that his client was merely doing her job as instructed by her employers. “She was asked by her boss to dole out funds to companies which later proved to be fake. But she did not know at the time these companies were fake. So she signed the credit facility documents using her name,” he said.

Purportedly bogus firms Wibowo Wadah Rejeki and Accent Investindo Indonesia received Rp 121.3 billion and Rp 60 billion, respectively, in loans.

“We are seeking justice for [Arga],” Humphrey said.

“Robert as well as Hermanus should take responsibility for their actions instead of trying to make an ordinary employee who knew nothing about what they were up to take the fall.”

Man Testifies He Joined Ahmadiyah Attack Last Year ‘to Be in The Group’

The Jakarta Globe
Man Testifies He Joined Ahmadiyah Attack Last Year ‘to Be in The Group’

Bogor. A villager told a court in West Java on Wednesday that he only joined a mob that attacked an Ahmadiyah Community in Bogor last October because he wanted to be part of the crowd.

Imam Tamawi told the Cibinong District Court that he had no idea why the mob burned down an Ahmadiyah mosque, schools and homes in the village of Cisalada.

The resident of Pasar Salasa village in Ciampea was testifying at the trial of the three men accused of inciting violence and destroying property in Cisalada, home to about 600 members of the besieged Islamic sect.

The defendants are Dede Novi, 18, Aldi Afriansyah, 23, and Akbar Ramanda, 17.

“I actually had no idea what they were going to do that night, but I just wanted to join them because they were so many of them and they were all walking togethe and heading somewhere,” Imam said. “I joined and ended up in Cisalada.

“I also started to throw the stinesm even though I actually had no idea why they were attacking the [Ahamadiyah] mosque in Cisalada. I felt I was part of the group.”

In response to a question by prosecutor Aji Sukartaji, Imam said that while he was pleating stone at the mosque, someone in the mob throw a molotov cocktail, but he didn’t see who was responsible.

“I could tell it was a Moloto cocktail from the sound it made. But I am not sure who threw it because it came from out of the crowd in front of me.” he said.

Matsuki, an officer from the Public Order Agency (Satpol PP), provided Wednesday’s hearing court with an account of what happened prior of the attack.

A resident of a neighboring Kebun Kopi village, Matsuki, told the court that a group of 30 men had arrived at his home and asked if the Public Order Officers planned to tear down the Ahmadiyah Mosque in Cisalada, which they claimed was in violation of the law.

Matsuki said the men left his home upset because he could not provide them with the answer they wanted to hear.

“They were disappointed with me. I told them that I had no authority to really say anything.” he told the court.

“They came to ask about the administration’s plan to tear down the Ahmadiyah mosque” he said.

“I am only an Satpol PP officer and I was in no position to give them a definite answer. Tearing down or sealing off a building requires an officer order.”

Matsuki told the court that after the men left his house, they headed west toward Cisalada.

“I had no idea that they would attack Cisalada after they came to see me,” he said.

“I was actually surprised that they wanted to talk to me. To my understanding, they had already had a meeting with officials from the local administration to discuss the matter of the Ahmadiyah mosque. I don’t know what they came out of that meeting. “

The court heard another witness, Dede Suryana, who told the hearing that he had seen and could identify two of accused attempting to burn down the mosque.

“Dede Novi was trying to burn some of the books in the mosque, including the Koran using matches, and Rama [Akbar Ramanda] was trying to destroy the roof of the mosque,” Suryana told the court.

During the hearing, the protesters outside the courthouse could be heard shouting anti-AHmadiyah slogans, including “Destroy Ahmadiyah, destroy Ahmadiyah, they are not Islam!”

Following the hearing, supporters of the defendants headed for Cisalada and appeared to be prepared to attack. Police in the village, however, were able to prevent any violence and detained five people.

Ministry to Sue New7Wonders Over Komodo Snub

The Jakarta Globe

The Culture and Tourism Ministry will sue the organizers of the New 7Wonders of Nature competition for removing it as the Komodo National Park’s official backer in the competition, a lawyer said on Wednesday.


Todung Mulya Lubis, representing the ministry in the suit, said the Swiss-based New7Wonders Foundation acted unfairly in dropping the ministry as the park’s official supporter. “It’s unfair because it was the ministry that first registered Komodo for the competition and signed the standard participation agreement,” Todung told the Jakarta Globe. “Therefore, we want them to reinstate the ministry as the official supporting organization.”

On Monday, New7Wonders said the ministry would no longer be allowed to officially support the park’s campaign because it had failed to meet its obligations.

In a statement posted on the foundation’s Web site, New7Wonders president Bernard Weber said the ministry had to be dropped in order to keep the national park in the contest.

“In the case of Komodo, the evidence clearly points to the unsuitability of the Ministry of Culture and Tourism as our authorized New7Wonders Official Supporting Committee,” he said.

The ministry also failed to meet requirements in its bid to host the awards ceremony for the competition’s winning entries later this year. However, Todung said it had never signed an agreement to host the ceremony, adding that Komodo’s participation in the New7Wonders campaign and Indonesia’s willingness to host the awards ceremony were two different things.

“Their decision to drop the ministry as the official supporting committee is an attempt to discredit Indonesia’s government and has no legal basis,” he said.

Culture and Tourism Minister Jero Wacik said the legal action against New7Wonders “to uphold Indonesia’s reputation.”

He added that he had never signed a contract with the foundation that would oblige the government to pay $10 million in licensing fees and Rp 420 billion ($47 million) to host the ceremony.

However, New7Wonders has denied asking for the latter sum, saying the government’s only commitment if it wanted to support the private consortium organizing the ceremony was around $10 million.

Husband Comes Out in Defense of Key Suspect

The Jakarta Globe

The husband of Nunun Nurbaetie Daradjatun, the missing link in the Miranda Goeltom corruption scandal, said on Tuesday that his wife was indeed ill and the constant negative media attention would only worsen her condition. 


Adang Daradjatun, Nunun’s husband and a former National Police deputy chief, asked journalists to respect the legal process taken by the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK). 

“Please, respect the principle of the presumption of innocence. Her position in this case is that of an eyewitness,” said Adang, who is also a Prosperous Justice Party (PKS) lawmaker. 

“Stop this character assassination by the media because it will aggravate her condition.” 

The KPK has been attempting to formally question Nunun since early last year. Four convicted former lawmakers identified her as the courier of Rp 24 billion ($2.7 million) worth of traveler’s checks allegedly used to buy legislators’ votes to appoint economist Miranda as senior deputy governor of Bank Indonesia in 2004. 

Nunun has ignored four summonses from the KPK, with her lawyers saying she is suffering from a mysterious amnesia-like illness, for which she is being treated in Singapore. 

Dr. Andreas Harry, a neurologist at Gading Pluit Hospital in North Jakarta, has been treating Nunun since 2009. 

“On July 25, 2009, Nunun suffered a stroke, the effects of which lasted for six months,” Andreas said. “But because her condition was not improving, I suggested that the family go to Singapore to get better treatment. That was when they went to Mount Elizabeth Hospital.” 

Andreas said that according to the most recent medical reports available, Nunun’s illness was not affecting her ability to speak, but it was causing memory loss similar to that seen in patients suffering from dementia. She appears physically healthy, he said, but her memory is poor. 

Adang would not say where Nunun was currently being treated, but welcomed an independent assessment of his wife’s health by a doctor appointed by the antigraft commission. 

“I just expect that the doctor would be a qualified doctor who could conduct a thorough examination of my wife,” he said. “I don’t want them to diagnose her from physical appearance alone. Her problem is internal.” 

Haryono Umar, a deputy chairman of the KPK, said the body would continue to monitor developments in the case and decide on its next step. 

“We do not have any immediate plan to send doctors to check Nunun’s health,” he said.

Shock: Bekasi FPI Leader Faces 6-Month Sentence for Role in HKBP Attack

The Jakarta Globe


Prosecutors stunned the courtroom audience on Monday when they demanded a mere six-month jail term for defendant Murhali Barda, one of 13 men standing trial for an attack on leaders of the Batak Christian Protestant Church (HKBP) in Bekasi last September.

Murhali is the suspended head of the Bekasi chapter of the Islamic Defenders Front (FPI). He was initially accused of inciting the attack through text messages and radio speeches as well as through his personal Facebook page.

The Sept. 12 attack saw the stabbing of Asia Sihombing and beating of Luspida Simandjuntak, both of whom are leaders of the congregation.

“We are recommending that Murhali be jailed for a maximum of six months, minus the time he has already spent in prison and fined Rp 1,000 [$0.11] in damages,” prosecutor Priorentha told the court hearing, saying Murhali had been proven guilty of violating Article 335 on unpleasant conduct. The article carries a maximum jail term of one year.

“He is a known cleric. He is guilty of encouraging his followers, whether through text messages or Facebook updates. But not a single eyewitness has said the cleric had issued instructions to attack the church leaders.”

Priorentha added that the mitigating factors prosecutors considered for Murhali were his politeness and good behavior in court and the fact that he had four small children who still needed his parental guidance.

“What has been proven against Murhali is that he had joined the protests against the HKBP, carried out orations rejecting the HKBP and their activities in Ciketing and sent out invitations to people to join protests,” he said.

Aside from violation of Article 335 on unpleasant conduct, Murhali had previously also been accused of violating Articles 170 and 160. Article 170 on assault and destruction of property carries a punishment of up to five years and six months. Article 160 on written or verbal provocation carries a maximum sentence of six years. Prosecutors decided not to include those charges.

Murhali’s lawyer, Shalih Manggara Sitompu,l said the sentence demand proved Murhali’s innocence in terms of provocation and damage to property as well as assault on the leaders.

“If Murhali had really violated the law, why did the prosecutors simply say he was guilty of [violating] Article 335, and did not mention Articles 170 and 160?” the lawyer said.

Prosecutors demanded harsher sentences for other defendants in the case.

Komodo Remains in 7Wonders Competition

The Jakarta Globe

The foundation that launched the New7Wonders of Nature competition announced on Monday that Komodo National Park in the Sunda Islands would remain in the running despite earlier threats to drop it.


However, the foundation said the Ministry of Culture and Tourism would no longer be allowed to act as the supporting committee for the park’s campaign.

The ministry had failed to meet several obligations as the park’s backer, prompting tensions with the New7Wonders team. The ministry also failed to meet requirements in its bid to host the declaration ceremony for the competition’s winning entries later this year.

New7Wonders president Bernard Weber said in a statement on the foundation’s Web site that the ministry had to be dropped in order to keep the national park in contention.

“In the case of Komodo, the evidence clearly points to the unsuitability of the Ministry of Culture and Tourism as our authorized New7Wonders Official Supporting Committee,” he said.

“Therefore, this status is revoked with immediate effect. This removal allows us to keep Komodo in the campaign.”

Weber said his organization refrained from a complete withdrawal after receiving “numerous and encouraging requests” to keep Komodo in the contest.

Nia Niscaya, the ministry’s director of conventions, declined to comment on the statement. “We’ll discuss with our lawyers how to respond,” Nia said on Monday

Yudhoyono ‘Regrets’ Fatal Attack on Ahmadiyah

The Jakarta Globe

As an attack on an Ahmadiyah community in Banten that left three dead was met with widespread condemnation, a spokesman on Sunday quoted President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono as merely “regretting” the incident.


Some 1,500 residents attacked 25 Ahmadiyah members who had refused to leave the house of a local group leader in Umbulan village, in the Cikeusik subdistrict of Pandeglang, at around 10 a.m. on Sunday, National Police Chief Gen. Timur Pradopo said.
Three members of the minority Muslim group were killed and six others injured in the attack.

“The president regrets that there were victims during the incident,” said Julian Aldrin Pasha, a spokesman for Yudhoyono. “Steps should be taken against those who violated the law.”

Julian said Yudhoyono had ordered Timur and Religious Affairs Minister Suryadharma Ali to go to Umbulan and also to explain the incident to the public.

“The government condemns whoever is behind violence against any Indonesian citizen,” said Djoko Suyanto, the coordinating minister for political, legal and security affairs.

Djoko promised a thorough investigation into the incident.

But he also called on the Ahmadiyah community to “respect the joint [ministerial] agreement signed in 2008,” referring to a decree banning the sect from worshiping in public and spreading its beliefs.

Condemnation of the attack came from political parties, social organizations and rights groups, including the House of Representatives faction of the National Awakening Party (PKB), the Ansor youth wing of Nahdlatul Ulama, the largest Islamic organization in the country, the Setara Institute for Democracy and Peace and the Wahid Institute.

The Wahid Institute said in a statement that it “strongly condemns” the attack, and that “this incident once again showed how security personnel failed to protect citizens.”

It called on Yudhoyono to take action. “Do not say in speeches that Indonesia protects religious freedom and then, when there are violations of religious freedom, stay silent and pretend like nothing happened,” it said.

The PKB House faction also “strongly condemned” the violence in a statement and lashed out at the assailants as “immoral human rights violators who acted contrary to the peaceful principle of Islamic teachings.”

It demanded that the attackers be arrested.

Setara urged the central government to take serious action following the attack. It also blamed the violence against the Ahmadiyah community on an edict issued by the Indonesian Council of Ulema (MUI) and on Suryadaharma, who has repeatedly voiced his desire to see the sect banned.

“The state should be firm, not weak, and not let any group or civilian militia disturb and disrupt the calm and peace,” Ansor chairman Nusron Wahid was quoted by Kompas online as saying.

Timur said the violence occurred as police were trying to get 25 people who had holed up in Ahmadiyah leader Ismail Suparman’s house to leave.

“We arrived and asked them to vacate the house but they refused. At the same time, some 1,500 villagers showed up and then the incident occurred,” he said. “I assure you that we shall really investigate this case.”

Malingping General Hospital told the Globe that all the victims had been stabbed and beaten by blunt objects.

Student’s Dreams Crushed After Thrown From Train

The Jakarta Globe

Ardi Rizki Yozho had just turned 17 and thought that his dreams were coming true. He loved trains and was proud to be the only student in his entire school to have secured an internship with state railway operator Kereta Api.


But today, Ardi lies in a hospital bed, his right leg amputated below the knee.

A week after turning 17 last month, he was thrown out of a moving freight train by a couple of cellphone thieves. His leg was crushed and beyond saving.

As fate would have it, Ardi had boarded the freight train even though he had bought a ticket for the passenger train to Bekasi, where he lives and studies.

“For some reason, I decided to board the freight train because it had arrived earlier than the KRL [electric train] heading to Bekasi,” Ardi said from his bed at Sumber Waras Hospital in West Jakarta.

A student of an automotive vocational senior high school in Bekasi, Ardi explained that he had been interning at KA for just a week in Tanah Abang, Central Jakarta, when the incident occurred on Jan. 25.

“One of my dreams was to become a train mechanic. To enhance my knowledge of trains, I had even joined a community of rail lovers here — the Komunitas Edan Sepur Indonesia,” he said, adding that he had also suffered serious injuries to his head as well as his left ankle.

Nevertheless, Ardi said he had accepted his fate and, following his recovery, hoped that KA would allow him to complete his internship. “Although I have lost my right leg, I still want to work as a mechanic at KA and I want to finish my internship at KA Tanah Abang,” he said.

“This has been my dream job since I was a little boy. But I don’t know whether or not I can really do it at this point.”

Ardi said that on the day of the incident, he ran into three other people hitching a ride aboard the freight train. “I was listening to music on my cellphone,” he said. “One of them asked me for a lighter. I lent it to him.

“The other two passengers suddenly approached me and told me to hand over my cellphone. I just ignored them, but they didn’t like that.”

Ardi said the next thing he knew he was being punched and kicked to the point that he blacked out. He doesn’t remember what happened after that.

“When I came around, I found that I was in the hospital. And that my leg was gone,” he said.

Zuhro Arsad, Ardi’s 56-year-old mother, has been at her son’s bedside since he was brought to the hospital by residents who found him unconscious near the rail line in Pasar Ikan, North Jakarta. The residents also contacted Zuhro.

“No police helped my son at that point. It was local residents who took the initiative to bring my injured son to a nearby hospital in North Jakarta with the help of a truck driver,” Zuhro said. “They had taken him to Atma Jaya Hospital in Pluit. It was the nearest one.”

She said that doctors had immediately operated on Ardi’s head injuries and tried to save his leg, but the next day the leg had to be amputated.

She said she was terrified about telling her son about his leg. “The doctor told me it was better that Ardi find out himself as it would be better for him psychologically. So, I didn’t say a word until he found out by himself,” she said.

Zuhro, who, like Ardi’s father, is a retiree, said that for now all the hospital bills were being covered by state health insurance, or Askes, which covers treatment only in state-run hospitals. However, there was still medication that they needed to pay for out of their own pockets.

“While Ardi was in the emergency room, we spent more than Rp 50 million [$5,500]. Although some of the expenses are paid for by Askes, we still need to pay some of the medication expenses by ourselves, which costs about Rp 1 million a day,” Zuhro said. “We will make an effort to pay all the medical expenses because all we want is to see Ardi get better. We will also find a way to send him to university.”

KA spokesman Mateta Rizalulhaq said he could not yet confirm the incident, but explained that if Ardi had been on the freight train illegally, state-owned insurance company Jasa Raharja would not cover his medical bills.

“If Ardi was a KRL passenger, then he could make a claim to Jasa Raharja,” Mateta said. “However, if he was an illegal passenger [on the freight train], then it will be difficult to make an insurance claim.”

Meanwhile, Egief Del Haris, a member of Komunitas Edan Sepur Indonesia, said he regretted Ardi’s decision to hitch a ride on the freight train, although he understood that passenger trains to Bekasi were not very regular.

“Actually, we really want to help Ardi in this case but, unfortunately, he didn’t take a KRL even though he bought the ticket,” he said, adding that the group, which has more than 2,000 members across the country, actively discouraged riding illegally on freight trains.

“We just hope that a similar accident will not happen to anyone else,” he said.

“It is just not right to take a freight train.”

Texting Defendant Sparks Courtroom Etiquette Debate

The Jakarta Globe

Bogor. Legal experts on Thursday had mixed reactions to the failure of a courtroom and its judges to take any action against a criminal defendant seen texting as well as reading text messages during the course of his trial.


Aldi Afriansyah, one of three defendants standing trial for destruction of property and inciting violence during an October riot in Bogor, was seen checking his mobile phone and texting on a number of occasions during the course of Wednesday’s trial.

At one point during the hearing at the Cibinong District Court, Aldi stuffed his cellphone, which had been on a vibrate mode, into his trouser pocket, before pulling it out again and reading a text message.

Aldi, along with 18-year-old Dede Novi and 17-year-old Akbar Ramanda, is accused of being part of a mob that burned down houses, schools and a mosque at the Bogor village on Oct. 1, home to 600 members of the Ahmadiyah, a minority Islamic sect.

Criminologist Adrianus Meilala from the University of Indonesia said that if judges, prosecutors and lawyers did not respect correct courtroom procedures practiced by a majority of courts worldwide, one could not expect criminal defendants to be any different.

“Using a mobile phone during an ongoing trial hearing is forbidden. But unfortunately, this is very common in Indonesia. In this trial, a defendant was witnessed being preoccupied by his cellphone while a witness was giving testimony. In other courtrooms across the country, you can find judges, prosecutors and lawyers busy with their phones during trial hearings,” Adrianus said.

“It is clear that people here have lost respect for the Indonesian courtroom. It is very different with courts in other countries such as Australia or the United States, where courtroom procedures are highly respected. No cellular phones. No cameras. No talking [among courtroom audiences] during an ongoing trial.”

Criminologist Mohammad Irvan Olii, however, offered a different opinion. He said that as long as the use of the cellular phone during ongoing trial hearings did not produce sounds or had its ring tone switched off, using the cellular phone was allowed.

“As long as the phone doesn’t disrupt trial proceedings, it’s not a problem” Irvan said.

Besides, he said, the use of cellular phones had not been regulated in the Criminal Code Procedures.

“If the [sitting] position of the defendant is not directly facing the panel of judges, which means that he or she is not testifying at that point, the use of a cellular phone is fine,” he said.

Legal expert Andi Asrun said he had expected the presiding judge to issue warnings to everyone inside the courtroom to close their cellular phones, pointing out judges too were not allowed to use their cellular phones during an ongoing trial.

“The presiding judge should have warned the defendant because his conduct violates courtroom discipline,” Andi said.

After three unheeded warnings, Andi said, the defendant could be charged.

“He could even end up with a higher sentence for interfering with the trial hearing.”

He said courtroom visitors are also often a problem.

“They are sometimes supporters of the defendants and cause a ruckus. They should follow the hearing in order.”

Following Wednesday’s hearing, as the case has been in at least two previous hearings, a throng of anti-Ahmadiyah protesters called out and attempted to block the safe exit of witnesses to the attack.